I love ice cream. Coming to New York City, I’ve made it my mission to try all the ice cream shops the city has to offer.
Working a job on the Upper East Side, I spent my night looking forward to a late-night treat. I had not really known much about Sedutto before visiting but had it bookmarked on my Maps as an ice cream shop to try. I was more than pleasantly surprised to find the shop lighting up the corner of 78th and 1st Ave.
I walked in to find a cheerful yet modern shop with a plethora of flavors, toppings, and choices. Having trouble making decisions, it took me a few minutes to get my bearings. They had over 40 flavors of hard ice cream, ranging from Red Velvet to Pumpkin to Banana Fudge to Green Tea. There was two full freezers in front with a list of more that they had in the back. They also had several soft serve ice cream choices. To narrow my options, I just considered the hard ice cream flavors. While contemplating what I should order, the man behind the counter let me taste try a few samples, one being Red Velvet. I finally decided on Birthday Cake and Midnight Cookies in Cream, two of their most popular flavors, in a cookie crumb waffle cone. I was amazed at the varieties of cones they offered. They had multiple speciality waffle cones in unique flavors like birthday cake, and of course the classic cake and sugar cones.
With the first bite of my ice cream I knew this place was a hit. Of all the other ice cream places I had tried so far, this was definitely the best quality. The Birthday Cake flavor was undeniably frosting sweet and had wonderful cake chucks perfectly mixed in. I often order this flavor, and Sedutto’s version was definitely one of the best. Reaching Midnight Cookies and Cream, I was amazed at the stark contrast between the sugary cake-like ice cream and a decidedly rich chocolate flavor. Midnight Cookies and Creams successfully combines the depth of chocolate with the classic taste of cookies and cream. My cookie waffle cone held up well, and the ice cream was hard set, allowing me to leisurely take my time-consuming this richly flavored ice cream.
I was sad when I finally reached the bottom of my cone, but I look forward to returning and trying some of the other hard-to-find flavors.. This ice cream shop is definitely a gem that does not get the attention it deserves.